OK just off the top of my head:

Underrated:
rrroll
pinky poo
frosty34
kersplatt
magenta_majors (i_suck)
retareded rock
mozzer
Beepa
johnson213
gadjet
manbearpig

awesome new schoolers
detenmile
debwa
potato27
Seahawk
BashOgreBash

good thing for me this list isnt the top 10 overrated kdice players..

This is honestly the dumbist shit I have ever seen.

3/07 = New schools jesus fucking christ that is dumb. At lest pick post elo to be new school. Also no one on the underated list is actually underated way to pick some random top 10 finishers of the last couple months and call them underated. Wow I really am having such a hard time getting by the stupidity shown here I almost want to believe this is a parody becaus J123 is a pretty cool guy and a decent player I would never expect the complete lack of any inteligence shown here to come from someone I liked and respected.

I mean what the fuck.

As for my contributions to this exercise in futility:

Underrated:
HanBaer
Smaks

New School (Post elo)
Bone Roller
DaShiVa

There are others I would add but I am to lazy to bother to look up people right now.

Final thought, OP failed at his purpose, mostly because he listed himself on the list.

lol, agreed! Dont post yourself on the list!

stoude most underrated.

he was playing the way people play now before it was the in thing to do.

if you want someone who knew the system, it was him.

Sam's underrated
Grun's overrated
DaShiVa's underrated
Montecarlo's overrated

If you don't know what ninja flagging is, you're new school. If you can name at least two moderators, you're new school.

Wicked's underrated
leekstep's overrated
bone roller's underrated
fiero is terribly overrated
sunvic is underrated
kdicefreak is overrated

The Fazer clan were innovators.

El D? what were you smoking?
nexon can't play without pga

johnson needs to make a new list.

who is judas???

so when I selected these kdicers...in my mind I was thinking what makes some of them underrated is the fact that everyone thinks they are overrated...it was my opinion...it can be faulty...and it is subject to change...I mostly did this to see what other people thought...and because monte told me I should post it in the forum...what a mISTAKE...I thought of the list in less than five minutes...I just wanted to see what others thought...and why can't I be on my own list?...If anything I should be criticized for having myself so low =D

Ok, I will post some comments here - not because I made it on the list- but because Johnson is a friend and because I honestly think he tried to make a good thread

I tried making a list too but I have to admit it is difficult: if I limit it too a few very clear underrated players, I can do it but once you go to 10, you can easily inlcude 25 because there are many good new players nowadays (so glad about that btw)

but how to define underrated? or even new school?

Not every good player makes it to top25 or even top 100. Some people like me have a nice family life and lots of other stuff to do outside of kdice. Playing 150 games a month is getting increasingly more difficult. So your rankings suffer. I just made it into top25 career but that won't last for long if I can only collect about 15k a month.

So it's been a few month now that I have been hoping Ryan could install an allstar league (something like 5 blue medals to qualify or 100-200k career?). The current ranks are fun but I think the time is right to add something new and exciting. It will be the ideal environment for old school and new school talents to compete and enjoy eachothers skill from day one of the month. Ryan suggested to me that lots of new stuff is to be added in July (well at least I think it was july?) so I am really looking forward to the new stuff.

to end this post on topic:

top 10 underrated will always be too hard to give, but give me a day or so to come up with an easier top5 list: top 5 of players that don't always make top25 due to insufficient number of games per month (high PPG or high %top3 finishes). But it will be a mix of newer players and more well known players.

Sure that would be cool :)