Forum
Scoring thoughts
|
Cyron wrote
at 4:45 PM, Sunday September 16, 2007 EDT
I was an initial fan of the new scoring system, but I must say that I'm coming to find it more and more annoying as time goes by. It really does seem that if you aren't 1st or 2nd, you may as well not have played for all of the points it will get you. +2 points for 3rd is just silly, and that's from a game where I bowed out as soon as it was clear I was not going to get more than 3rd rather than hanging on and giving away points.
It seems to me that if the scoring system is going to be like a game of poker, each turn should be considered a hand, so that a kitty is split between players each turn rather than as each player bows out. It seems to me that would make the scoring a little more even, as someone in 3rd for most of the game would, turn by turn be getting slightly more points each turn than they are paying out in ante, at least until there are only 4 players left. It would then let the player in 3rd walk away with points at this stage if there was no way he could win. As it is now, he either keeps giving points to 1s/2nd and hopes that the guy in 4th finally flags, or he takes 4th himself, costing himself a chunk of chips he had actually earned |
« First
‹ Previous
Replies 11 - 19 of 19
|
DoobiusMalcor wrote
at 3:36 PM, Monday September 17, 2007 EDT n00bs who don't know history are doomed to repeat it.
|
|
Bedevere wrote
at 4:27 PM, Monday September 17, 2007 EDT Yes, dom or something else is necessary to prevent all those people who are losing from trucing with the 1st place guy and ending up with a high place after just sitting there the whole game.
|
|
skrumgaer wrote
at 7:09 PM, Monday September 17, 2007 EDT From your replies to my query it looks like dom still serves a useful purpose.
|
|
penubag wrote
at 11:59 PM, Monday September 17, 2007 EDT I agree with Cyron, we need to be awarded more points not just 1st place and 2nd.
|
|
hydrocodone wrote
at 5:49 PM, Tuesday September 18, 2007 EDT Wait did Doob just call Skrum a "noob."
Oh snap! Clown v. math wiz grudge match! |
|
skrumgaer wrote
at 6:50 PM, Tuesday September 18, 2007 EDT What history is going to be repeated?
|
|
rnd wrote
at 7:36 PM, Tuesday September 18, 2007 EDT I think RND is going to win the month again.
|
|
JKD wrote
at 1:03 AM, Wednesday September 19, 2007 EDT These numbers aren't exact but before it used to be common for 1st to get +48 and an away player to get +32. So if you were 5th (-16) you'd get ticked off at losing a good amount of points to away player or small turtle ally.
|
|
JKD wrote
at 1:12 AM, Wednesday September 19, 2007 EDT And then add elo to that. Away players tended to be low score so it seemed a lot worse than it was.
Dom is a great idea to get people to *play* kdice instead of turtling, but it also means you'll have to settle for losing a lot of points to an insane player every now and then. |