I loved them at dice wars!!! always enlightened a smoke and enjoyed victory ... again (only when I won of course)! Probably very hard to realize, but if possible: YEAH!

yes

yes!

This Is a great idea. I think one should also be able to download the reply with comments and all. I'd love to be able to do kDice commentary on my blog.

I'd love the idea. Especially to review games and such.

You've got my vote! However, all that extra data processing could be a train wreck for the servers. :O

yes, excellent idea!

I have wanted to go back in a game to see what went wrong so many times, so, yes.

And watch all the PGA action

it wouldn't be a big load on teh servers, or real hard to do, I don't think.
just record the starting positions, then each turn record the attack and who won. optionally log the chat window also.
for replay, load the map, instead of randomizing the start, load in the recorded start data, then play as normal, on each turn, rather than taking user input, take the logged input and play it. then instead of randomizing the rolls, just assign a winner from that log. optionally actual dice rolls could be logged, but thats overkill.