Forum


My thoughts on Wishbone's thoughts.
XCRobin wrote
at 12:17 PM, Thursday October 2, 2008 EDT
I decided to make a new thread for this, mostly because I wasn't sure if Wish wanted to keep his retirement post about himself and not about the things he actually said in his post. But he got me thinking. No, not about he was one of the only, if not the only, to play one account. (-1 for a 1st. Classic.)

I noticed that the Story According to Wishbone seems to play out rather linearly. There's one team. Then there's two. Then there's more. What caused this expansion of teams? I'd like to think that’s just based upon community awareness.

Back when the Faz0r clan started teaming up at tables, no doubt they were the only ones. Seeing as they accounted for 10 of maybe 100 people playing the game in December 06, I'd say that had a decent monopoly. Most lost interest in the game. So enter rnd. What made rnd's original PGA so effective. IT WAS SECRET. No one knew about it. When you checked the forums, there’s rarely a mention of a pre-game alliance. It was all about scoring changes, bugs, random thoughts, even "higher thinking." It was a secret club that you had to be inducted into. Most of the community didn't know it existed, and, in a way, it was better then.

As the cabal inducted more members the concept of PGA began spreading. The other top players soon noticed and brought about the end to the original cabal. The difference was, this was done publicly. If you read the posts from May 2007 you will see that the secret was out. No longer was PGA restricted to a few people, now everyone knew about it and it was rampant. There were counter-PGA PGA's, Spanish cabals, blah blah blah. Read Wish’s post for more information.

Regardless, the old era of kdice was ushered out by this new information of what PGA was, how to do it, and everything else. And here we are today.

Am I advocating PGA? No. I am just trying to point out that when PGA became public knowledge, it changed the game. Should PGA have been kept a secret? Maybe, maybe not. Each camp has its own thoughts on the subject. However, no one can refute the fact that by making the knowledge of what a pre-game alliance is, and by thrusting it in everyone's faces was a pivotal moment for kdice.

I personally think that this dissemination of information was a bad thing for the community as a whole. Sure, it made everyone on a similar page, and got a lot of things out in the open. I believe however that it was toxic to the community. The wars of '07 were fun, engaging conflicts that only had digital outcomes. The wars of '08 are spiteful. They're becoming attacks on people’s personal lives. So if the cabal was still working in secret, would there have been a kdicefreak, Pat Whalen, Fiero600 as a moderator?

Once the secret got out, the world was turned upside down.

Replies 1 - 10 of 13 Next › Last »
fiero600 wrote
at 2:11 PM, Thursday October 2, 2008 EDT
I specifically was a moderator to spite you actually.
JDizzle787 wrote
at 3:36 PM, Thursday October 2, 2008 EDT
I wholeheartedly agree with 90% of your post. I agree that it is still toxic to the community, but I never believed that any of the "wars" unless you mean between PGA teams, were fun.


The public knowledge of PGA and other methods have and continue to warp the judgment of our benevolent creator in punishment (Ryan, you're awesome, but I still disagree with your methods).

Also, it would've been impossible for the cabal to keep quiet. And there have been players nuts about the fairness of the game almost since it's conception. Also, one key detail people tend to forget: remember those arguments with Mikeinrussia about "friends"?
montecarlo wrote
at 3:50 PM, Thursday October 2, 2008 EDT
doesnt seem to matter how many times i try to explain what the cabal was, people still try to warp the truth to further their own claims and beliefs.

but i will never get tired of repeating my experience of what the cabal was. my experience is not second-hand. my observation didnt come from outside (like leekstep and everyone else after him who claim to know exactly what the cabal was and did). this is genuine inside information, no bias applied, just an account of my experience. only two people might have a better grasp of what happened in the cabal: rnd and integral. they were the only two higher up the cabal chain than i was. well, maybe a third has more of a grasp than i: comik. he knew a lot of the shit, but didnt care to get involved.

anyways...

the cabal basically revolved around one relationship: integral was rnd's bitch. integral didnt mind rnd getting all the spotlight, he was cool with letting rnd take a greater percentage of 1sts. int really didnt care too much for png trophies. rnd did, and wanted everyone to know that not only was he the best, but also that if you didnt give him the respect he demanded, then he could destroy your kdice experience.

it needs to be emphasized that every member of the cabal had a different personality, and different interactions with other members of the cabal. int didnt mind rnd taking the spotlight, or rnd lording it over him as though he truly was a better player than int. when i came into the circle, i appreciated int's personality, the whole 'i dont care for ultimate authority' thing, so he and i got along just fine. my personal experience with rnd... well, it was fun to witness his antics, to watch everyone else bitch as i protected his ass and gave him an undeserved 2nd, or to watch him exact revenge on so many people who called into question his majesty of majesties. but i would butt heads with him fairly regularly because i would only split 1sts with him. if i won the game, and felt i deserved the 1st, i goddamn well took it. he didnt like this, he wanted me to flag out 2nd, and let him take the first, because thats what the cabal was all about: helping rnd. but this is where i disagreed with him, i didnt give a shit about making explicitly rnd's score higher. i wanted to split the rewards of the pga evenly. this is where int and i differed, int preferred being the bitch.

im not so sure about dasfury's involvement in the cabal (he can tell us himself), but he came after me. we all joked that das was always the bitch of the cabal, because whenever 2 of us sat in a game together, das would get 2nd. whenever 3 sat together, das would get 3rd. whenever the cabal would lose a game, das was told to flag out 7th, so rnd or whoever could get at least a 4th or something.

wishbone came in soon after das, and i got along with him much better than i got along even with int. wish has (or had at least) a very erratic personality, would have insane turns, type in all caps constantly (actually holding shift). and i like that personality, that says what he feels, no holds barred.

Vermont was, in my opinion, the typical caballer. he joined without realizing it, he loved being nice to some members (like me and das), and purely hated other members (rnd). when he found out that one of the cabals primary goals was to feed rnd points, he had a minor aneurysm, quit the game for 3 hours, then quit the cabal.

see, this is the enigma about the cabal: there was never an all-important goal to it. there was never a tight rein on who is part of it and who is not. there were other members of the cabal whom i completely detested (riser), and never played with. across this mass of people, there was plenty of conflicting interests. the only constant, really, was that int was rnds bitch.

im not saying it wasnt cheating, it definitely was. sitting in with a pga dramatically increased your odds at winning, especially when you are trucing others at the table in-game as well.

my only issue is that people who werent a part of the cabal, or people who formed the anticabal, or people who joined the game well after the cabal broke up... they all make these completely offbase statements concerning the cabal that are nowhere close to the truth.

the biggest misconception i can think of: cabal members agree to never attack each other. i pged rnd for weeks, whenever i felt his ego was getting out of control. i felt the need to make sure he knew that he didnt control me. it would get to the point that he would not sit down at the same table as me.

anyways, sorry to spout off. its just that i saw wish and xc post megalong posts, so i felt the urge to compete.
CoMik wrote
at 4:00 PM, Thursday October 2, 2008 EDT
Well I won't be that long. But Monte's view of the cabal is fairly accurate. Though the only times I played with the cabal, I was the one that was given games. Meh. Int was clearly the better player, but adam had what most kdice 1st place people have, obsession. That's all I can be bothered to say on the subject.
XCBatman wrote
at 4:48 PM, Thursday October 2, 2008 EDT
Nice post Monte. Looks like you missed the point.
ChristianSoldier wrote
at 5:06 PM, Thursday October 2, 2008 EDT
What a genuine thrill to reflect on the so many times I denied rnd the pleasure of my joining his filthy little network. Though I miss him.
sunvic wrote
at 5:54 PM, Thursday October 2, 2008 EDT
i didn't read it but i disagree because you typed it.
.10. wrote
at 7:28 PM, Thursday October 2, 2008 EDT
Typing all that about an online dice game seems slightly pathetic
JDizzle787 wrote
at 7:52 PM, Thursday October 2, 2008 EDT
oh boy .10
Johnson213 wrote
at 8:01 PM, Thursday October 2, 2008 EDT
lol@ i disagree bc you typed it
KDice - Multiplayer Dice War
KDice is a multiplayer strategy online game played in monthly competitions. It's like Risk. The goal is to win every territory on the map.
CREATED BY RYAN © 2006 - 2026
GAMES
G GPokr
Texas Holdem Poker
K KDice
Online Strategy
X XSketch
Online Pictionary